Golfers agreeing who will play together

Group selection rules are the written policies that say who may book a tee time for a group, how big that group can be, when they may book and what happens when two groups want the same slot. Clubs that settle these points in advance, publish them and apply them the same way every week remove most of the arguments about Saturday mornings. This guide sets out what to decide, with examples from UK clubs and one widely used tie-break method.

Ballchute
ballchute.co.uk
Make Busy Tee-Time Booking Fairer
BallChute gives members a club-controlled waiting room to choose tee times in turn, without the pressure of competing clicks.
Explore BallChute

TL;DR

  • Decide five things in writing: who can book for a group, how far ahead, the maximum group size, how guests count, and how clashes are settled.
  • Real club rule books show the range: 7 and 14-day windows, a three-guest limit, and a yearly cap on guest introductions.
  • For competing requests, a points-based ranking with a lottery for ties is an established, explainable method.
  • Rules only work if members can see them where they book, and if the booking system applies them for you.
  • A waiting room with turn-based booking can enforce your group rules without a click race.

Table of Contents

What group selection means when booking golf tee times

In a golf club, a group is the set of players who want to go out together in one tee time, usually two to four. Group selection is the part of booking where one person, or the system, picks the time on behalf of that group, and where the club’s rules decide whether the request is allowed.

That covers more than choosing a slot. It includes who is entitled to ask (full members, juniors, visitors), how many names can go on one booking, whether the booker must play, and how a club chooses between groups when demand outstrips the sheet. If you have landed here from the biology or physics meaning of the phrase, this page is about golf bookings only.

Most clubs already have these rules somewhere: a members’ handbook, a noticeboard, a committee minute. The trouble starts when they are vague, scattered or applied differently by different people. A good rule set is short, specific and visible at the point of booking.

The five decisions every rule set needs

Before you write any wording, settle these. Each one is a place where members tend to disagree if you leave it open.

Decision Question to answer Example of a clear answer
Who books Can any member book for others, or only for themselves and their own group? A member may book a group only if they are playing in it
When How far ahead, and does it differ by membership type or competition? 7 days for general play, 14 days for club matchplay ties
Size What is the minimum and maximum group? Two to four players, with singles paired when busy
Guests How many per round, how many per year, who must accompany them? Up to three per round, host must stay with guests
Clashes How are two groups wanting the same time resolved? Ranked by agreed criteria, lottery for ties

The sections below take these in turn, using published rules from clubs that have written them down.

Who can book, and how far ahead

Booking windows are the first rule members notice, because they decide who gets the good times. UK clubs publish a range of approaches.

Fortrose & Rosemarkie Golf Club allows all tee times to be booked up to 14 days in advance. That is a simple, single window, which is easy to explain and easy to enforce.

Some clubs use different windows for different kinds of play. Kirkcaldy Golf Club requires club matchplay ties to be booked directly through the club rather than the standard online channel, with a 14-day window compared with 7 days for casual play. The reasoning is clear: a tie involves two named opponents with a deadline, so it deserves more notice than a casual game.

Others tie the window to membership category. Whipsnade Park Golf Club gives 7-day members priority two-week advance booking, while lifestyle members have a 7-day window. Whatever you think of tiered access, it is stated openly on the membership page, which is half the battle.

When you set your own windows, ask three questions:

  1. Does the window match how members actually plan, or does it just move the scramble to a different day?
  2. If categories differ, can you explain the difference in one sentence to a member who gets the shorter window?
  3. Do competitions and matchplay ties need their own, longer window?

A longer window does not remove the rush on release. It only changes which morning it happens. That is why many clubs pair the window with a controlled release, covered later.

Group size and eligibility

Group size sounds obvious, but eligibility rules are where most disputes sit: guests, juniors, visitors, and the person who books a block “for friends”.

Fortrose & Rosemarkie is a useful model because its rules are specific. Members may introduce up to three guests per round, must play with them, and the guests must be signed in with the host staying with them. The same document sets a cap of 12 guest introductions per member each year. Three numbers (three, host plays, 12) answer most of the questions a member will ask at the desk.

When you draft your own eligibility rules, state:

  • the minimum and maximum number of players in one booking;
  • whether the person making the booking must be one of the players;
  • how many guests a member can bring per round and per year;
  • what guests must do on arrival, such as signing in;
  • who has priority when membership categories compete for the same time, and who decides.

On that last point, Fortrose states that member priority is at the discretion of the Council and is indicated on the club’s online booking system. Naming the decision-maker and showing the outcome where members book is a sound habit.

Settling competing group requests

When two groups want the same time and your system cannot take both, you need a tie-break that members accept as fair. There are broadly three types: first come first served, a ballot, and a ranking by agreed criteria.

First come first served is simple, but it rewards fast connections and fast fingers rather than anything the club values. A pure ballot is fair but ignores everything else. A ranking sits between them.

One established ranking method in golf is the Chelsea system. Under it, groups are ranked by the average points of their members, lowest average first, with an automated lottery when groups requesting the same time have equal points. A second club document describes the same principle: group requests are prioritised by the average points earned by the group’s members, with the lowest average considered first. The idea is that a group who have been getting the poorer times in recent requests move up the queue. Note that both documents come from clubs outside the UK, so treat it as a model to adapt rather than a UK standard.

Whatever method you choose, write down:

  • the criterion (points, time since last preferred slot, membership category);
  • the tie-break (lottery, earliest request, alphabetical is best avoided);
  • who runs it and when results are published.

A second fairness question is what happens when you have to move people. Delapre Golf Centre’s policy is that it will not move a member’s booking earlier and will shift it no more than one tee time later during busy periods. That is a clear, limited promise: members know the worst case.

Busy tee sheets and misuse of group bookings

Every group rule gets tested by the same behaviours: block bookings, placeholders, and slots held for people who never play.

Holding slots for non-players. Delapre Golf Centre explicitly forbids members from reserving bookings for visitors unless the member intends to play in that group. It is a one-line rule that closes the most common loophole.

Pairing up. The same club pairs members up when the course is busy, but not before 9:30am at weekends. A paired-times approach is also described by PlayMore Golf’s help centre as a way to improve course use and stop single players blocking a whole slot. If you pair singles, say when it applies and when it does not.

Protected times. Some times are not for general booking. Milnathort Golf Club gives green staff priority on the course until 9:00am daily to prepare for play. Kirkcaldy allows only two-ball games in the 20 minutes before stroke competitions with a reserved first tee. Rules like these should be built into the sheet so members cannot select the time at all, rather than relying on someone to cancel later.

Cancellations. A group booking that is never cancelled is a slot nobody else can use. Pair your group rules with a clear tee time cancellation policy so a released slot returns to the sheet in good time.

Telling members the rules, and applying them the same way

A rule nobody can find is a rule nobody follows. Three habits keep rule sets credible.

  1. Put the rules where members book. Fortrose’s approach of showing priority on the booking system itself is the best example in this research: the member sees the outcome at the moment it matters.
  2. Name who decides exceptions. A committee, a secretary or a manager, not “the club”.
  3. Review on a schedule. Look at the sheet after a season. Which slots filled in seconds? Who complained? Change one thing at a time, and trial it before it is permanent. Our note on piloting a fairer release schedule covers how a committee can do this without a vote on an untested idea.

Consistency matters more than the exact numbers. A 7-day window applied to everyone is easier to defend than a clever system applied unevenly.

A sample rule set you can adapt

This is a template, not a club’s policy. Adjust the numbers to your own course and membership.

  1. A booking is for one to four players. The person making it must be playing.
  2. Members may book 7 days ahead for general play. Matchplay ties and competition entries use a 14-day window.
  3. A member may bring up to three guests per round, must play with them, and may introduce no more than an agreed number per year.
  4. Early morning and pre-competition times are held back for greenkeeping and competition use and cannot be selected in general booking.
  5. If two groups request the same time at release, the group with the fewest recent preferred times goes first. Equal claims are settled by lottery.
  6. Cancellations must be made by an agreed deadline, after which the slot is released to others.
  7. Exceptions are decided by the competition secretary, and the decision is recorded.

Try it against a real Saturday. If a member could read those seven lines and predict what would happen to their group, the rules are doing their job.

Our view: fairness is a process, not a rule

We build tee-time booking for golf clubs, and the pattern we see is that written rules are rarely the problem. Most clubs already have sensible ones. The problem is that the moment popular times are released, the real rule becomes whoever clicks first. A member on a slow connection, or one who is less confident online, loses to a rule nobody wrote.

So we think the release itself needs rules. Members join an online waiting room, take their turn to choose, and have a time limit set by the club, so nobody has to race. The club defines the order, the time allowed and who can book for whom. That lets your group selection rules actually be the rules that apply on the day.

We are also clear about what this is not: it does not replace your membership or competition management system. It focuses on high-demand releases and works alongside what you already use. If you want the longer argument, our piece on why a Saturday tee time is harder to get goes through it, and our comparison of waiting rooms, fastest-finger booking and ballots sets out the options by type.

— Simon

Putting group rules into a waiting room

BallChute lets a club run its own booking queue with its own limits: turn-based booking, group selection, member verification, and tee sheets you can download or have emailed. You can try it free for 14 days, with no automatic fees afterwards.

Pricing is per club. The Standard plan is £29 per month or £290 per year. Clubs on Intelligent Golf membership systems can use the Intelligent Golf plan at £35 per month or £350 per year. To see how a waiting room works before you change any rules, read how clubs fix the booking scramble with a waiting room, or see how members join a fair club queue.

FAQ

What are group selection rules in golf?

They are a club’s written policies on who may book a tee time for a group, how many players and guests it can include, how far ahead it can be booked and how competing requests are settled. They are usually found in a members’ handbook, playing regulations or on the booking page.

How far ahead should a club let members book?

There is no single answer. The UK clubs reviewed here use windows of 7 and 14 days, sometimes with a longer window for matchplay ties or for certain membership categories. Choose a window you can explain simply and apply to everyone in the same category.

How many guests can a member bring?

That is set by each club. One example is Fortrose & Rosemarkie, which allows up to three guests per round, requires the member to play with them and caps guest introductions at 12 per member a year. Check your own club’s rules before booking.

What is the fairest way to settle two groups wanting the same time?

A ranking with an agreed criterion and a lottery for ties is one established answer, as in the Chelsea system. Whatever you pick, publish the method and the person who runs it, so members can see why a result came out as it did.

Can software enforce group rules?

Yes, if the rules are built into the booking flow: group size limits, verified members, time limits per turn and held-back times. Rules enforced by the system are applied the same way to every member.

Sources

Recommended